Thanks to LRC, I just had the pleasure (?) of watching this American tax propaganda video from the World War II era:
We hear the usual claptrap in this clip, words like “duty” and “sacrifice.” The interesting thing about “sacrifice,” however, is that it is a lie: When a thief breaks into your home and takes your most treasured possessions, that is not a sacrifice. The divestment of your materials was not voluntary, so how could there be any giving or sacrifice? In the Jewish and Christian traditions, sacrifice is voluntary. I suppose that this means that the State is more like primordial religions, in which even human sacrifice was conducted without the consent of those whom it, well, impacted the most, if you catch my drift.
Another interesting feature of this excrement is that it glorifies violence and serving the State in the military. What else are all those salutes and “Yes Sirs” meant to convey? Couple this with the surprise when the talking radio reveals he’s actually discussing the income tax. This seems to re-enforce the idea that military service is assumed to be good.
Interestingly, however, one does wonder why the government, through its shills at Disney, felt the need to make this cartoon. At the time the federal income tax was not a very old thing; many would have remembered much more peaceful times when they kept much more of their money. Was there some resistance still? How did the government prevail? Were people as gullible then as they are now? It would seem that tyranny benefits, if you’ll pardon my constantly bringing up this idea, from fragmentation and obsession, as Weaver called it. This is the myopic fetish with detail that humanity has developed after it has lost sight of civilization’s founding principles. The most obvious symptom of this is naked hostility to philosophy, most often seen in the neo-conservatives. But the salient point here is that fragmentation and obsession keeps us from seeing the essential characteristics of a thing. Indeed, to point out the relationship between theft and taxation is to waste one’s breath even in conversations with the “fiscally conservative.” The government benefits from this because of the consequent stupidity which makes people more pliable to the idea that paying taxes is “different” from being robbed at gunpoint.
There is one tiny, tiny redeeming piece of this video, however. It would seem that it shows how the tax system worked before the withholding racket got its start. Would that each of us, every April 15, had to write a check for every cent in tax that we “owe” for the previous year. That is to say, abolish the withholding system. It is a nice trick the government uses, and it keeps most people, who are asleep in general as it is, from realizing just how much tax they pay every year. It was sold to the gullible as a “convenience” but it is really a weapon: Employers are required to withhold the money, and there is no chance for people to say to the government, “You’re not getting it.” It makes any kind of tax revolt well impossible, doesn’t it?
For my part, I continue to pay my taxes honestly, if only out of a sense of prudence. I value my ability to live freely over my natural right to keep the fruits of my labor. I am like the coward who, when confronted with a gun-wielding mugger, hands over his wallet without even thinking. Perhaps, however, the point should not be my cowardice, but rather that the government—that evil, parasitical pile of excrement in Washington—relies on such conundrums for its survival.
Remember that the next time some sports announcer asks you to stand up for the State Song. “Deutschland ueber Alles…” Ooops. Wrong soundtrack. Well, they’re all the same, though, aren’t they?